Autism: Understanding Personal Construct Theory for Parents

Decoding Your Child’s World: Using Personal Construct Theory to Improve Communication with Autistic Children

Have you ever felt like you were talking to your child in a foreign language, even when you were both speaking English? You tell your teenager, “Clean your room, it’s a disaster!” fully intending to motivate them, but are met with resistance and an exasperated, “It’s fine!” Perhaps your younger child bursts into tears when a classmate playfully bumps into them in the hallway. These everyday misunderstandings can be frustrating for both parents and children, and are often rooted in differing perspectives. This is where Personal Construct Theory (PCT) offers valuable insights for bridging communication gaps and strengthening relationships, especially when it comes to understanding and supporting autistic children.

Understanding Personal Construct Theory

Developed by psychologist George Kelly in the 1950s, Personal Construct Theory offers a unique way of understanding how individuals make sense of the world. The theory’s central premise is stated by Kelly: “A person’s processes are psychologically channelized by the way in which he anticipates events”. In simpler terms, this means that our unique experiences act as filters, shaping how we interpret and react to the world around us. We don’t passively absorb information; rather, we actively construct our own understanding based on our past encounters, values, and beliefs.

This concept is particularly relevant when parenting autistic children, who often experience the world in ways that may be quite different from neurotypical individuals. By understanding and applying PCT, parents can gain valuable insights into their child’s perspective and improve communication and understanding.

Our Mental Filters: Understanding Constructs

Imagine an autistic child who has repeatedly been criticized for their unique way of playing or interacting with toys. They might develop a construct that associates playtime with negative feelings like anxiety or shame. This construct, like a mental filter, will influence how they approach any play-related activity in the future. They might avoid playing with others, become easily overwhelmed in playgrounds, or become distressed when expected to engage in “typical” play scenarios.

These mental filters, which Kelly called constructs, help us navigate the complexities of life by categorizing and making sense of our experiences. Just as a scientist develops hypotheses and tests them against observations, we all develop constructs based on our individual experiences and use them to anticipate and interpret future events. However, because our constructs are deeply personal and often subconscious, they can lead to misunderstandings when we assume that others see the world through the same lens.

For autistic children, these constructs can be particularly strong and inflexible. They might develop very specific expectations about how certain activities should unfold or how people should behave in certain situations. When reality doesn’t match these constructs, it can lead to anxiety, meltdowns, or withdrawal.

The Impact of Constructs on Behavior in Autistic Children

Recognizing the impact of constructs on behavior is crucial for understanding why our children act the way they do, especially in social situations. An autistic child who has had negative experiences with loud noises might develop a construct that associates noise with danger or discomfort. Consequently, they might cover their ears, become agitated, or try to escape when in noisy environments.

This understanding is particularly important when supporting autistic children. Many autistic individuals face significant challenges in social communication and interaction. They might misinterpret social cues, struggle to understand figurative language, or have difficulty recognizing and responding to the emotions of others. These challenges can be better understood through the lens of Personal Construct Theory.

For example, an autistic child might develop a construct that associates eye contact with discomfort or sensory overload. As a result, they might avoid making eye contact during conversations, which could be misinterpreted by others as disinterest or rudeness. Understanding that this behavior is rooted in the child’s personal constructs can help parents and others respond with empathy and find alternative ways to ensure the child feels engaged and understood.

Building Bridges of Communication: Practical Tips for Parents of Autistic Children

While we can never fully step into another person’s world and see things exactly as they do, PCT offers practical strategies for building bridges of understanding and improving communication with our autistic children. As Jim Sinclair, a prominent autistic self-advocate, eloquently puts it, “…work with me to build bridges between us”.

Applying Personal Construct Theory Principles to Interactions

Here are some ways to apply PCT principles in your daily interactions with your autistic child:

1. Practice Active Listening: Give your child your undivided attention when they are talking to you. Put away distractions and use nonverbal cues to show that you are engaged in the conversation. For autistic children who may struggle with eye contact, consider sitting side-by-side or engaging in a shared activity while talking. This means going beyond simply hearing the words; it involves paying attention to tone of voice, body language, and any unspoken emotions being conveyed.
2. Ask Open-Ended Questions: Instead of asking yes/no questions, encourage your child to elaborate on their thoughts and feelings. For example, instead of asking, “Did you have a good day at school?” try, “What was the most interesting thing you learned today?” This invites them to share their experiences in their own words and helps you understand their perspective. Be patient and allow extra time for your autistic child to process the question and formulate their response.
3. Reflect Back What You Hear: Repeat back to your child what you have understood, both verbally and emotionally. For example, you might say, “It sounds like you’re feeling frustrated because the schedule changed unexpectedly.” This shows them that you are listening and trying to understand their perspective, even if you don’t fully relate to their experience. For autistic children who may struggle with emotional expression, this can be particularly helpful in validating their feelings and experiences.
4. Validate Their Feelings: Let your child know that their feelings are valid, even if you don’t agree with their perspective. For example, you might say, “I understand why you’re upset. It’s okay to feel that way.” Avoid dismissing or minimizing their feelings, as this can make them feel unheard and misunderstood. This is especially important for autistic children who may experience emotions intensely or have difficulty regulating their emotions.
5. Be Patient and Understanding: Remember that communication is a two-way street. It takes time and effort to build bridges of understanding, especially when there are significant differences in perspective. Don’t expect overnight transformations; approach each interaction as an opportunity to learn and connect with your child. Autistic children may need more time to process information and respond, so patience is key.
6. Respect Sensory Needs: Be aware of your child’s sensory sensitivities and preferences. Create a communication-friendly environment by minimising sensory distractions or providing sensory tools that help your child feel comfortable and focused.
7. Embrace Special Interests: Many autistic children have intense interests in specific topics. Use these interests as a way to connect and communicate. Engage in conversations about their favorite subjects, and use these topics as a bridge to introduce new concepts or ideas.
8. Be Literal and Clear: Autistic children often interpret language literally. Avoid sarcasm, idioms, or figurative language that might be confusing. Be clear and direct in your communication, and explain abstract concepts when necessary.
9. Recognize and Respect Different Communication Styles: Some autistic children may communicate more effectively through writing, typing, or using augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) devices. Be open to these different forms of communication and support your child in using the methods that work best for them.

Applying PCT to Understand Autistic Perspectives

Personal Construct Theory can be particularly illuminating when trying to understand the unique perspectives of autistic individuals. Here are some examples of how PCT can help parents better understand and support their autistic children:

1. Routines and Predictability: Many autistic children thrive on routines and struggle with unexpected changes. Through the lens of PCT, we can understand that these children have developed constructs that associate predictability with safety and comfort. When routines are disrupted, it challenges their fundamental understanding of how the world works, leading to anxiety or distress. PCT-Informed Approach: Work with your child to create visual schedules and provide advance notice of changes whenever possible. Help them develop flexible thinking by gradually introducing small, manageable changes within a supportive framework.
2. Sensory Experiences: Autistic individuals often experience sensory input differently than neurotypical people. What might seem like a mild sound or texture to you could be overwhelming or painful for your child. Their constructs related to sensory experiences may be fundamentally different from yours. PCT-Informed Approach: Validate your child’s sensory experiences, even if you don’t share them. Work together to identify triggers and develop coping strategies. This might include creating quiet spaces, using noise-canceling headphones, or avoiding certain textures in clothing or food.
3. Social Interactions: Many autistic children struggle with unwritten social rules and nuances. Their constructs about social interactions may be based on explicit, learned rules rather than intuitive understanding. PCT-Informed Approach: Help your child develop social scripts and explicit strategies for navigating social situations. Explain social rules clearly and provide opportunities for practice in safe, supportive environments.
4. Special Interests: Intense focus on specific topics is common among autistic individuals. These special interests often form a central part of their personal construct system, shaping how they view and interact with the world. PCT-Informed Approach: Embrace and celebrate your child’s special interests. Use them as motivators, learning tools, and bridges to other areas of development. Help your child understand how their interests connect to broader concepts and skills.
5. Emotional Regulation: Autistic children may have difficulty identifying and expressing their emotions in ways that neurotypical individuals easily understand. Their constructs around emotional experiences may be quite different from what you expect. PCT-Informed Approach: Work with your child to develop a shared emotional vocabulary. This might include using visual emotion charts, discussing characters’ feelings in stories, or using metaphors that resonate with your child’s way of thinking.

The Power of Perspective-Taking

One of the most valuable aspects of Personal Construct Theory is its emphasis on perspective-taking. By recognizing that each individual, including our autistic children, has a unique set of constructs through which they interpret the world, we can approach parenting with greater empathy and understanding.

Consider this example: Your autistic child becomes upset when asked to transition from one activity to another. Rather than seeing this as defiance or inflexibility, PCT encourages us to consider how this situation might look from the child’s perspective. Perhaps, in their construct system, abrupt transitions feel like a loss of control or a disruption to their sense of order. By understanding this, we can work with our child to develop strategies that make transitions smoother and less anxiety-provoking.

Embracing Neurodiversity through PCT

Personal Construct Theory aligns well with the concept of neurodiversity, which views neurological differences like autism as natural variations in human cognition rather than deficits or disorders. By applying PCT in our interactions with autistic children, we acknowledge and respect their unique ways of perceiving and interacting with the world in a neurodiversity-affirming way.

This approach encourages parents to move beyond trying to “fix” or change their autistic child to fit neurotypical norms. Instead, it promotes understanding, adaptation, and mutual growth. By recognizing and working with our children’s personal constructs, we can help them develop strategies to navigate a world that may not always align with their natural tendencies, while also advocating for acceptance and accommodation of neurodivergent perspectives in society.

Conclusion: PCT as a Tool for Understanding and Connection

In an increasingly complex and demanding world, effective communication is essential for fostering strong relationships, building resilience, and promoting emotional well-being. Personal Construct Theory, with its emphasis on empathy, active listening, and understanding individual perspectives, provides a powerful framework for decoding your autistic child’s world and building stronger connections.

By recognizing that meaning is constructed, not inherent, we can approach conversations with greater curiosity, openness, and a willingness to bridge the gaps between our perceptions. This shift in mindset can make all the difference in creating a more supportive and understanding environment where our autistic children feel safe to express themselves, navigate challenges, and reach their full potential.

Remember, every autistic child is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. The key is to remain patient, open-minded, and willing to learn from your child. By applying the principles of Personal Construct Theory, you can develop a deeper understanding of your child’s perspective and create a more harmonious and supportive family environment.

For further exploration of PCT and its applications, George Kelly’s (1955) book The Psychology of Personal Constructs is an excellent resource. Additionally, numerous websites and online communities offer insights and support for parents interested in learning more about this approach to understanding and supporting autistic children.

References:

Bradley-Cole, K., Denicolo, P. and Daniels, M. (2023) ‘It’s the Way I Tell Them. A Personal Construct Psychology Method for Analysing Narratives’, Journal of Constructivist Psychology, 36(4), pp. 467–482. doi: 10.1080/10720537.2023.2168806.

Mark Murphy (2014). Using Personal Construct Psychology to Explore Relationships for Adolescents with High Functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder – ProQuest. [online] Available at: https://www.proquest.com/openview/1526ea476d9806e79d06c1c69a882323/1?cbl=18750&diss=y&loginDisplay=true&pq-origsite=gscholar [Accessed 1 Oct. 2024].

‌